Truemag

  • Newsletters
  • Thought Leadership
  • Mobility
  • Safety
  • Work Trucks
  • Videos
  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Who We Are

NETS Study: Addressing Driver Fatigue is Best Route to Significantly Lower Fleet Crash Rates

Ten more practices also found very effective

By Mark Boada, Executive Editor

Taking steps to combat driver fatigue has the greatest effect on reducing fleet crash rates, according to a recently published study of 70 U.S. fleets conducted by the Network of Employers for Traffic Safety (NETS). Calculations of the raw results by Fleet Management Weekly showed that fatigue risk management practices were associated with crash rates that were as much as 77% lower than fleets that didn’t rely on them.

The study, which appears in the December issue of Safety Science, also found at least ten more practices associated with crash rates that were more than 20% lower, by at least one measure, than those of fleets that didn’t follow them. In descending order, the five most effective include reviewing driver mobile phone records after all crashes (up to 58% lower), providing some form of driver training for all employees (45% lower), post-collision reviews that take crash severity into account (30% lower), checking the motor vehicle records of new hires (42% lower), and banning the use of mobile phones while driving (25% lower).

One surprising finding was that fleets that employ in-vehicle driver monitoring systems but only review the data after serious crashes have a higher average crash rate than both fleets that don’t have them at all and those that review the data after every crash. The average crash rate for fleets in the study that deploy such devices – irrespective of whether they review the data after a crash – was 8.4%, compared to 13.4% for fleets that reviewed it only after “serious” crashes, a rate that is nearly 60% higher.

On the other hand, it found that the average crash rate for fleets that reviewed the data after every crash was and 7.4%. That was 33% lower than the average for fleets (11.06%) that don’t use in-vehicle monitoring devices.

Wide range of industries, fleet sizes and type
The authors of the article say the study was the first to appear in a peer-reviewed journal to compare fleet safety practices and policies for a large number of fleets with actual safety outcomes. It is based on fleet responses to a survey that focused on fleets’ 2016 safety programs and their reported performance data.

The study compared the crash rates of fleets that relied on specific kinds of safety policies and practices against those that did not employ them. It did not, however, compare fleets’ crash rates before and after they adopted the practices. Study participants were all NETS members from a wide range of industries and, together, operated all classes of vehicles, from light to heavy-duty. Fleet sizes ranged from as few as 136 vehicles to as many as 51,000.

The fleets reported a range of 2016 crash rates according to two measures: the percentage of fleet vehicles involved in crashes (Fleet Percent) and crashes per million miles driven (CPMM); it also recorded fleet drivers’ average injuries per million miles driven (IPMM). The companies surveyed reported an average Fleet Percent crash rate of 10.1%, CPMM of 4.94 and IPMM of 0.27. While Fleet Management Weekly isn’t aware of verified statistics that have been compiled for the fleet industry as a whole, these numbers are believed to be below those for the average fleet. For example, it is widely believed that the average fleet has a 20% crash rate.

Fatigue risk management practices
The study looked at many different types of fatigue management practices. The one associated with the greatest difference in fleet crash rates was conducting medical screenings for fatigue. Depending on crash rate measurement, the practice was associated with average crash rates that were 65% to 77% lower.

Other measures to combat fatigue that were statistically linked to lower crash rates were conducting fatigue management training for new hires (average rates that were 70% to 74% lower); restrictions on night driving (52% to 65%), and fatigue management refresher courses for existing drivers (31%). The study also found that the more of these programs offered, the lower their average crash rate.

Other beneficial practices

The study also noted that fleets that followed the following practices also accounted for a lower average crash rate:

• Completing driver commentary drives (41% lower)
• Publishing the fleet safety scorecard to drivers (28% lower)
• Championing of driver safety by corporate executives (IPPM rate lower by 60%; the study did not show the effect on Fleet Percent or CPMM rates)

The article appears in Volume 120 of Safety Science. The title is “The relationships among roadway safety management practices, collision rates, and injury rates within company fleets.” The authors are Jonathon M. Vivoda, Assistant Professor of Sociology and Gerontology at Miami University (Ohio); Stephanie G. Pratt, PhD, Director of the Center for Motor Vehicle Safety at the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, and Susan J. Gillies, manager of marketing and operations analysis at NETS.

Nov 29, 2019Janice
Chevin Touts Flexibility, Functionality of FleetWave Forms Mobile AppFleet Liability: The Risks of a Self-Reporting Policy
Recent Posts
  • Isuzu Partners with ChargePoint on EV Charging Network for its Commercial Trucks
  • California Governor Vetoes Bill Requiring Humans in Autonomous Big Rigs
  • Global Smart Fleet Management Market is Anticipated to Reach US $962.6 Billion by 2031
  • UAW Strike Set to Hit Deep into the Industry’s Supply Base
  • Announcing NETS 2023 Sector Meetings!
  • John Walsh Appointed EO Charging’s Chief Commercial Officer, Americas
  • Cross-Industry Partnerships Increase Consumer Likelihood for BEV Purchase Consideration
  • Opportunities Abound for Women in Trucking
  • Ford Introduces Hybrid Tech to Mid-size Truck segment with Ranger Plug-in EV
  • WIFM Keynote Speaker Sherine Clarke Presents ‘Embrace Your Personal Power’ at AFLA Conference
ASSOCIATION NEWS
WIFM Keynote Speaker Sherine Clarke Presents ‘Embrace Your Personal Power’ at AFLA Conference
EVs & Reducing Emissions at AFLA 2023
NAFA Seminar in New Orleans: Essentials of Fleet Management
Upcoming AFLA 2023 Conference to Highlight Safety and KPIs
NAFA Announces Winners of 2023 Green Fleet Awards
AFLA & WIFM: The Value of Mentorship
AFLA Learning Webinar: Risk & Safety – Driving Under the Influence
TECHNOLOGY
You May Soon be Able to Unlock Your Car with an IPhone or Apple Watch
Motorq Joins Mercedes-Benz to Transform Fleet Analytics, Connected Vehicle Insights
Tesla’s New Car-Building Process Could be a Huge Industrial Breakthrough
Fleetio Appoints Tyson Goeltz as CRO to Drive Revenue Growth
The Role AI May Play in Keeping Vehicle Repair Costs in Check for Fleets
10 Common Mistakes to Avoid When Charging Your EV
This Revolutionary Breakthrough Could Help EVS Drive 10 Times Longer Before They Need a Recharge
CONFERENCES & WEBINARS
Announcing NETS 2023 Sector Meetings!
WIFM Keynote Speaker Sherine Clarke Presents ‘Embrace Your Personal Power’ at AFLA Conference
EVs & Reducing Emissions at AFLA 2023
NETS Strength in Numbers Conference: Last Day for Special Hotel Rate is September 12
NAFA Seminar in New Orleans: Essentials of Fleet Management
Upcoming AFLA 2023 Conference to Highlight Safety and KPIs
NETS ‘Strength IN Numbers’ Conference: Keynote Speakers Announced for Indy
INDUSTRY ANNOUNCEMENTS
UAW Strike Set to Hit Deep into the Industry’s Supply Base
Announcing NETS 2023 Sector Meetings!
John Walsh Appointed EO Charging’s Chief Commercial Officer, Americas
WIFM Keynote Speaker Sherine Clarke Presents ‘Embrace Your Personal Power’ at AFLA Conference
How Fleet Marketing How Can Generate More Sales Opportunities
EVs & Reducing Emissions at AFLA 2023
ALD | LeasePlan Releases its Strategic Plan and Financial Objectives to 2026

Fleet Management Weekly Newsletter Archive
Access to back issues of the FMW newsletter.

FMW Mobility
How mobility is rapidly changing the fleet management landscape.

Newsletter

Subscribe

FMW Fleet Videos
Video clips of industry leaders speaking on a variety of engaging hot topics in fleet.

2014-2020 © Fleet Management Weekly