Truemag

  • Newsletters
  • Thought Leadership
  • Mobility
  • Safety
  • Work Trucks
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Who We Are

Negligent Entrustment: Ignorance Is Not Bliss or an Excuse

By Amber Wuollet, Manager of Marketing, SuperVision

Picture this scenario: It’s nearing the end of the work day and it has been a productive, but uneventful day — thank goodness — and you’re almost ready to head home for a well-earned evening of relaxation. Just as you’re getting ready to walk out the door, you get a phone call. One of your drivers rear-ended another vehicle on his way back to the office.

Aside from the damage done to the front of his vehicle and the back of the other car’s, the vehicle he hit was occupied by a family with several small children in the backseat. Thankfully, no one suffered any serious injuries. Still, you can’t help but think of the headache that lies ahead.

As you put the fleet accident protocol into play — and prepare to brief your superiors — many questions will start to run through your mind.

How fast was he driving when he rear-ended the vehicle? Was he driving distracted/using his cell phone? When was the last time his driving record was checked? Is his license valid or suspended? Has he had any other incidents in the past? How about any incidents in the past year? When was the last time he went through any sort of driver training? Is his vehicle in good condition? When was the last time his vehicle was checked for maintenance? In short, what was the driver’s risk profile?

DRIVER BEHAVIOR IS THE BIGGEST SOURCE OF FLEET LIABILITY

Be prepared. Not knowing what violations are on a driver’s license may be deemed negligent entrustment, which is the act of entrusting an automobile with a driver who the owner (in this case the fleet) knows could use the vehicle to cause harm to others based on previous behavior. Negligent entrustment and other associated vehicle safety lawsuits have become a common concern and worry for fleet managers. Companies have an ongoing obligation to track drivers’ licenses if they continue providing a vehicle and putting them on the road with other motorists.

Any company that has drivers is at risk for these types of lawsuits. The question is, how well prepared are you to defend yourself and your company in the event one should occur?

If litigation occurs as a result of an employee driving a company vehicle, the plaintiff’s attorney will ask to review your written fleet policy guidelines and how well it was enforced. Prior exceptions to fleet policy, if discovered (and it most certainly will), will likely render the fleet and its company vulnerable to negligent entrustment or negligent retention allegations.

DEFENDING AGAINST NEGLIGENT ENTRUSTMENT

A proactive approach, working in advance to improve fleet safety rather than reacting after the fact to incidents, will go hand-in-hand to positively impact a company’s risk profile and bottom line in the long run.

Employers should know who they’re entrusting their valuable and costly assets with. Most states impose liability when an employer knew or should have known that an employee was unfit to drive a vehicle or that a vehicle was unsafe. This means that companies must be able to show that they did everything they reasonably could to prevent accidents; otherwise actions you did or didn’t take might be construed as negligent entrustment.

STEPS TO COVER YOUR BASES:

1. Background check: During the hiring process, companies should conduct a comprehensive background check on every potential hire, including his or her motor vehicle record (MVR). This is the first step in helping you build a case that you proactively monitored the fleet’s drivers.
2. Training: Once hired, all drivers should receive on-going training, particularly if they’ve been identified as having an elevated risk profile. Along with continued driver safety awareness, providing a comprehensive classroom and behind-the-wheel training program at the time of new-hire training is an effective way to stress that safety is an important corporate value. On-going training is important to demonstrate that a company took care to ensure its drivers were qualified and remain up-to-date on new policies, rules, technologies, etc.
3. Fleet Safety Program: In many ways, defending against negligent entrustment is about establishing procedures and processes that are enforced to ensure a safety work environment. When an employee driver is involved in an accident and a plaintiff’s attorney comes knocking, you need to be able to produce documentation of any inappropriate actions that were due to the driver, and proof that you did whatever you could to address the incident and improve the driver’s risk profile.
4. Continuous MVR Monitoring: An annual MVR doesn’t cut it these days when constant, continuous MVR monitoring is available at a low cost, and has been proven to effectively alert fleet managers about any driving violations in a timely manner. Compare the cost of $15 per driver per year to all the costs associated with a vehicle accident, and in a worst-case scenario, a liability lawsuit, which could run into the millions and seriously damage the company’s reputation.

While continuous MVR monitoring isn’t the only step fleets should take to eliminate risk — it’s the cornerstone of a proactive fleet safety policy, and one of the best precautions that a company can take to prepare in advance for potentially defending themselves in a liability lawsuit.

Continuous MVR monitoring is the foundation of establishing the safety culture, and shows that your company acts proactively to any MVR violation. Download the whitepaper “Liability: Why ‘Good Enough’ Isn’t Good Enough” to learn more about liability, negligent entrustment and continuous MVR monitoring.

Visit eSuperVision.com to download the white paper

May 6, 2019Janice
Collaboration and Teamwork: Mission-CriticalUnderstanding How Marijuana Affects Driving
You Might Also Like
 
Why Fleet Accident Costs Could Soar in 2016
 
Register Now for NAFA’s CAFM® Information Management Boot Camp — May 3 & 4!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Recent Posts
  • Shell Announces Partnership with Spiffy to Offer Mobile Fleet Services
  • As Chip Shortage Cripples Auto Production, Biden Steps in
  • iPhone Maker Foxconn is Developing an Electric Car with Auto Startup Fisker
  • Chevin Fleet Solutions Moves Up a Gear with a New Website and Brand Identity
  • WORK TRUCK WEEK™ 2021 GOES LIVE ONLINE MARCH 8th through the 12th
  • This Is The Next USPS Mail Truck
  • Vehicle Relocation Logistics Opens Countless Ways to Drive Business Success
  • Porsche Claims Its Synthetic Fuel Could Make Combustion Engines as Clean as EVs
  • A Deeper Look at the Wheels – OnStar Partnership’s Value for Fleets
  • Getting Tough on Safety & Minimizing Data Overload
ASSOCIATION NEWS
WORK TRUCK WEEK™ 2021 GOES LIVE ONLINE MARCH 8th through the 12th
Work Truck Week 2021 Highlights Path Toward Zero Emissions
AFLA Corporate Fleet Conference 2021: Emerging Stronger
NAFA & The 100 Best Fleets in the Americas: 4 Essential Traits for 2021 & Beyond
The Ultimate Guide to Understanding Fleet Utilization & Achieving a Right-Sized Fleet
NAFA 2021 Institute & Expo Rescheduled to August
2020 NETS Conference Reveals Latest Fleet Safety Best Practices
TECHNOLOGY
A Deeper Look at the Wheels – OnStar Partnership’s Value for Fleets
Tech Platform Advises Don’t Take Your Eyes Off Distracted Driving
Apple Maps and Siri Will Combine to Let You Report Problems on the Road
How the US Plans to Capture the EV Battery Market
GM Flaunts Its Battery Technology in a Super Bowl Ad Blitz
Amazon is Installing AI-Powered Cameras in its Delivery Vans to Monitor Driver Behavior
Merchants Fleet Slated to be BrightDrop’s First Fleet Management Customer, Second Major Customer Overall
CONFERENCES & WEBINARS
WORK TRUCK WEEK™ 2021 GOES LIVE ONLINE MARCH 8th through the 12th
Work Truck Week 2021 Highlights Path Toward Zero Emissions
AFLA Corporate Fleet Conference 2021: Emerging Stronger
NAFA 2021 Institute & Expo Rescheduled to August
2020 NETS Conference Reveals Latest Fleet Safety Best Practices
NETS Virtual Strength IN Numbers®Fleet Safety Benchmark Conference
Tom Johnson Receives NAFA’s Honorary Lifetime Membership Award
INDUSTRY ANNOUNCEMENTS
Jeff Jenkins Joins RTA as VP of Sales & Marketing
RepairSmith Welcomes Senior Executives to Leadership Team
Merchants Fleet 2021 Outlook
FMW Welcomes Donald Dunphy
Holman Enterprises Names Chris Conroy President and COO
Michael Stafford Named Sales Director, Western Region, at Lordstown Motors
Fleet Industry Expert Steve Saltzgiver Joins RTA

Fleet Management Weekly Newsletter Archive
Access to back issues of the FMW newsletter.

FMW Mobility
How mobility is rapidly changing the fleet management landscape.

Newsletter

Subscribe

FMW Fleet Videos
Video clips of industry leaders speaking on a variety of engaging hot topics in fleet.

2014-2020 © Fleet Management Weekly