Truemag

  • Newsletters
  • Thought Leadership
  • Mobility
  • Safety
  • Work Trucks
  • Videos
  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Who We Are

Clutter or clarity: How soon will automakers banish buttons?

The Car Connection

You certainly wouldn’t be an outlier to think that a vehicle dash that’s cluttered with individual buttons looks so dated.

It’s been nine years since Apple introduced the first iPhone, which replaced the typical cellphone’s suite of buttons and replaced it with a capacitive touch screen and a home button.

And with as much time that we spend with our smartphones and tablets, it’s not surprising that consumer preferences for vehicle interfaces are closely mimicking that of the devices they carry in their pocket.

When the consulting firm IHS recently asked a wide range of consumers about in-vehicle interface possibilities that included individual buttons and knobs, multi-function controllers, touch screens, speech recognition, steering-wheel controls, and gesture recognition, users prefer touch screens first and speech second.

What is surprising is that the trend held true across all generations—even for those 70 years old or more.

“This is actually a situation where we’re seeing all ages adopt similar technology preferences,” said Mark Boyadjis, principal analyst at IHS Automotive, a consulting and market research firm.

Smartphone-like interfaces transcend generations

Boyadjis explains that there may be some variations by age, but “on the whole, the preferences toward speech recognition and touch screen are pretty broad, because no matter what generation you’re in you’re probably using a smartphone, and that familiarity becomes foreign wheh the car you get into doesn’t have a touch screen.”

The big issue here, Boyadjis says, is that OEMs can’t just check the box and say they have a touch screen and speech recognition. It’s the implementation that matters; and that easily transfers to end-user satisfaction, and ultimately to better customer loyalty and feedback.

That’s now being factored into customer perceptions of quality. Infotainment-system issues with voice controls and capacitive controls have recently pushed down certain automakers’ dependability and quality ratings, as measured by J.D. Power, for instance.

There are of course other interface options for replacing traditional buttons. One that Millennials (and younger respondents in general) responded more favorably about was the multi-function controller or touchpad—of the type used by systems such as BMW’s iDrive, Audi’s MMI, or Lexus’ Remote Touch.

Very few respondents in general knew about gesture recognition—making selections without actually touching the screen—but for that the preference rate was also much higher among Millennials.

As IHS found younger shoppers expected voice commands to affect a wider array of vehicles functions, including climate control, while older shoppers preferred voice controls most for calling, testing, and apps.

Read more of the original article in The Car Connection.

May 15, 2016connieshedron
Up to 25% MPG Improvement with XL HybridsWhy Three Repair Bids Can Be Worse than One
Recent Posts
  • FLD 2026 Q2 White Metal Market Report: Used Work Vehicle Market Slogs Through Summer
  • Aging Fleets Are Forcing a New Approach to Maintenance
  • It’s All Downhill from Here!
  • AFLA Announces New Board Members
  • Fuel Spend, Fraud and More: Is Your Fleet Data Working Hard Enough
  • GM Has Found a More Profitable Way to Make Money from Your Car
  • Amazon Added 10,000 Rivian Electric Vans In Just Six Months
  • What Are You Going to Do If the Gas Runs Out?
  • Driver Death Rates Remain High for Small Cars, Models with Powerful Engines
  • Distracted Driving Enforcement Is Expanding. The Cost to Fleets Goes Far Beyond the Ticket.
ASSOCIATION NEWS
AFLA Announces New Board Members
The Hourglass Foundation Named AFLA’s Charity of the Year for the Third Consecutive Year
AFLA Membership Growth: Mary Saunders on Engagement and the Value of Connection
How AFLA Is Positioning Itself for the Future of Fleet Mobility
Last Chance to Save: Register for NAFA’s Maintenance Workshop
‘Raise Your Hand and Get Involved’
NAFA Names 2026 Class of Fellows, Honoring Leaders in Fleet Management
TECHNOLOGY
Fleetio Customers Reject $41.6M in Unnecessary Repair Costs as AI-Powered Maintenance Scales
ServiceUp Launches Agentic Platform to Fully Automate Fleet Repair and Maintenance
America’s First UL-Certified Plug-In Balcony Solar Microinverter Is Here
As Fleet Tech Enthusiasm Tempers, New Study Reveals Path to Reactivate Adoption
The Fleet Manager’s Breaking Point: Why AI Must Do More Than Advise
All New Cars in the EU Now Need to Have a Camera Aimed at the Driver’s Face in the Latest Privacy Nightmare
The Grid Was Melting Down in Last Week’s Heat – Until EVs Came to the Rescue
CONFERENCES & WEBINARS
AFLA 2026: Keynote Speakers You Won’t Want to Miss!
Motus Webinar: One Platform for U.S. & Canada Employee Drivers
NETS 2026 Conference: Keynotes Confirmed; Road Safety Award Nominee Deadline
For The Leaders In The Room
2026 NETS Strength IN Numbers Conference: Early Bird Rates!
AFLA 2026 – Keynotes Announced!
Private Fleets Flex at National Private Truck Council Conference
INDUSTRY ANNOUNCEMENTS
Fleets: Preparing for Natural Disasters
Union Leasing Becomes Moventum Fleet Management as 70-Year Company Accelerates into Next Phase
Fleetio Wins Innovations Award at NAFA’s 2026 Institute & Expo
WIFM is heading to NAFA!
Cox Automotive Unveils Cox Fleet, Setting a New Standard for Fleet Uptime Nationwide
AFLA Canadian Fleet Professional of the Year Award: Nominations Open!
NAFA Webinar: Kickoff the 2026 100 Best Fleets Contest on December 4!

Fleet Management Weekly Newsletter Archive
Access to back issues of the FMW newsletter.

FMW Mobility
How mobility is rapidly changing the fleet management landscape.

Newsletter

Subscribe

FMW Fleet Videos
Video clips of industry leaders speaking on a variety of engaging hot topics in fleet.

2014-2020 © Fleet Management Weekly